First draft finished – whew

So after reading and writing for about a week, and a couple of months of reading before that I am finally finished my first draft of this essay.  Hattip to those who are going to read it over!

With the completion, and some (small I hope) revision I am finished my last history essay for my bacheolors degree.  I am hoping it is considered a solid essay but if not I am still happy with it.

One thing writing it has done is made me very curious about one of the key figures of the Anti-polygamist Crusade, Senator George Edmunds.  Reading his take on Mormonism in the Harper’s Magazine I was impressed with his grasp on what the Mormon leaders were attempting to do.  I do think he came to faulty conclusions but he still seems like he was one of the more interesting Gilded Age Senators.

The other thing of note, how many of these books are written by women.  I was surprised that many of the later, and in some cases better works are written by the likes of Sarah Barringer Gordon, Kathleen Flake, Jessie Embry and Joan Smyth Iverson.  I express surprise not from the standpoint of the women, but I am left to wonder why more men do not write about this era, especially in the last 10 years.

Anyway fascinating stuff, I heartily recommend the following books for a basis of understanding the era:

The Mormon Question: Polygamy and Constitutional Conflict in the Nineteenth Century, written by Sarah Barringer Gordon.  It was the book I felt offered an interesting perspective on the politics and legal fight for and against polygamy.

Mormon Polygamist Families written by Jessica Embry.  It breaks down a lot of the details of Mormon society and does so in a way that offers some sense that there was  a lot of variation in these plural marriages.

The Politics of American Relgious Identity: The Seating of Senator Reed Smoot, Mormon Apostle.  I have talked about Professor Flakes’ work elsewhere so go read it there.

Mormon Polygamy: A History by Richard Von Wagoner, I think this book worked as a good overview of polygamy, while it is not in depth enough for me it certainly pointed you to the salient points.

Joan Smyth Iverson’s work on the Mormon Woman’s Suffrage movement is fascinating and a topic I knew little about before reading her work on it. 

Anyway there is my overall review and mini annotiated bibliography.

UPDATE: Thanks to David in #1. It now reads corrected Jessie. I corrected things now so if Jessie should ever read this blog let me apologise. I hate it when I do that because I have always had a pet peeve about people mispelling my name.

Advertisements

5 Responses to First draft finished – whew

  1. David G. says:

    Er, Jon, that should be Jesse, not Jessica, Embry.

  2. Jon W says:

    ok I have updated the correct info. Thanks David

  3. Sanford Barrett says:

    Congratulations Jon, as usual I am enjoying watching your progress and seeing the sources you draw upon. I read the Embry book a few years ago and was delighted to see that my great grandfather, Warriner Ahaz Porter, and several of his children were referenced. The book helped me to see how people actually made polygamy work. Do you think you might post your paper when you are done? It sounds like an interesting read.

  4. Jon W says:

    Thanks Sanford, it is interesting to see your relatives in print.

    My Mom’s family settled Newmarket Ontario and there is a book talking about their lives, it was very interesting to read, especially when they would take the door off their cabin to act as a sled when they went to their (quaker) church.

    Fascinating stuff.

  5. Warriner was a brother of my great grandfather Edson Darius. Good going.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: